Why This Level Comes First
Every skill in this course, from sit to recall to calm alone time, uses the same method: reward the behaviour you want. The RSPCA, Dogs Trust and the Kennel Club all recommend reward-based training. The RSPCA puts it simply: all training should be reward based. This level explains why the method works, which methods to avoid, and how to give rewards that actually teach.
How Dogs Learn From Consequences
Dogs repeat what works for them. If something good follows a behaviour, the dog is more likely to do that behaviour again. If nothing good follows, the behaviour slowly fades.
An everyday example: you pay for coffee and get a free cookie, so you go back to that café. Your dog does the same. If sitting by the door makes the walk happen, your dog will sit by the door more often.
Here is what happens step by step:
- The dog does something, for example sits.
- Something good follows straight away, such as a piece of chicken.
- The dog links the action to the result.
- The behaviour becomes more likely the next time.
Trainers call this positive reinforcement: adding something the dog likes after a behaviour so that the behaviour happens more often.
The same rule works when you don't intend it. If your dog jumps up and you laugh, push them away or talk to them, that attention can reward the jumping. What to do: for one day, notice what your dog gets straight after each thing it does. You will start to see why it repeats some behaviours.
What Aversive Methods Are
An aversive method tries to change behaviour by causing pain, discomfort, fear or a fright. Common examples:
- Electric shock (e-collars): using hand-held, remote-controlled shock collars on dogs and cats has been banned in England since 1 February 2024 and in Wales since 2010.
- Prong (pinch) collars and choke chains: they tighten or dig into the neck when the dog pulls.
- Spray or noise devices: for example citronella collars, rattle cans or throwing objects to startle the dog.
- Physical punishment: hitting, smacking, yanking the lead, or pinning the dog down (sometimes sold as being "the alpha").
- Shouting and intimidation: looming over the dog or scaring it into stopping.
The Kennel Club is firmly against any aversive training device. Dogs Trust does not recommend training equipment that changes behaviour by causing pain or fear.
Why Aversive Methods Are Not Recommended
Aversive methods can stop a behaviour for a while, but they cost a lot. The main risks are:
- Fear and stress. Studies have found more stress behaviours in dogs trained this way, and these dogs can become more pessimistic.
- Damage to trust. The dog may link the pain to you, the lead, other dogs or children who happened to be nearby, instead of to its own behaviour.
- Hidden warnings. A dog punished for growling may stop growling but stay just as frightened, so a later bite can seem to come "out of nowhere".
- No new skill. Punishment shows the dog what not to do. It does not teach what to do instead.
- No better results. A University of Lincoln study found shock collars were no more effective than reward-based training, even in the hands of professional e-collar trainers.
Rule: if a method relies on pain, fear or force, don't use it.
Choose Your Rewards
A reward is whatever your dog wants at that moment, not what you think it should want. Options:
- Food: small, soft, smelly treats such as cheese, sausage or chicken for hard tasks, and dry biscuits for easy ones.
- Toys and play: a quick game of tug or fetch.
- Attention and praise: most dogs enjoy being looked at, talked to and stroked.
- Everyday rewards: sniffing, going through a door, being let off lead in a safe place, or greeting a friend.
What to do:
- Write a list of 5 to 10 things your dog loves.
- Rank them from "nice" to "amazing".
- Save the top-ranked rewards for difficult moments, such as busy places or new skills.
- If you train with food, give smaller meals that day so your dog doesn't put on weight.
Reward at the Right Moment
Timing matters more than the size of the treat. Dogs connect a reward with whatever they were doing at that moment. A reward that arrives late teaches the wrong thing: if your dog sits, stands up, and only then gets the treat, you have rewarded standing.
Follow these steps:
- Have rewards ready in a pocket or pouch before you start.
- Mark the moment. Say a short, cheerful marker word such as "Yes!" exactly when the behaviour happens.
- Reward straight away. Always follow the marker with the reward, during the behaviour or within about a second of it.
- Keep sessions short and fun: a few minutes, ending while your dog is still keen.
- Reduce food rewards gradually once your dog knows a behaviour reliably. Reward every other time, then every third time, and mix in praise and play.
Key Takeaways
- Behaviours followed by something good happen more often. This is positive reinforcement.
- The RSPCA, Dogs Trust and the Kennel Club recommend reward-based training and advise against aversive methods.
- Aversive methods, such as shock, prong or choke collars, spray devices, hitting and shouting, can cause fear and stress, damage trust and hide warning signs.
- Remote-controlled shock collars are banned in England (since 1 February 2024) and Wales (since 2010).
- Your dog decides what counts as a reward. Rank its favourites and save the best for hard tasks.
- Mark the moment and reward straight away. Late rewards teach the wrong behaviour.