LevelUpWith

Explore / Reward-Based Dog Training for UK Owners / Lesson 2

Lesson 2: Choosing a Breed or Rescue Dog Responsibly

Learn how to match a dog to your lifestyle and find a puppy or rescue dog from a responsible breeder or a reputable rehoming centre.

Free to read, no account needed. Part of Reward-Based Dog Training for UK Owners.

By the end of this level you'll be able to

  • Compare breeds and types by energy, size, grooming needs and typical behaviour, and judge how well they fit your home and routine
  • Spot the warning signs of puppy farms and irresponsible sellers, and list the questions to ask a breeder or rescue centre
  • Weigh up the cost, time and commitment of owning a dog over its whole life before you decide

Choosing a Breed or Rescue Dog Responsibly

In Level 1 you saw that reward-based training works best when you set your dog up to succeed. Choosing a dog that suits your life is part of that. A dog that fits your home and routine is easier to train and less likely to develop problems. This level covers three tasks: matching a dog to your lifestyle, finding a responsible source, and checking the lifetime commitment.

Task 1: Audit your lifestyle first

Before you look at any dogs, write down honest answers to these questions:

  1. Time: How many hours a day is your home empty? How much time can you give to walks, training and play every day, in all weathers?
  2. Space: Do you live in a flat or a house? Do you have a secure garden?
  3. Activity level: Is your ideal weekend a long hill walk or the sofa?
  4. People: Who lives with you or visits often? Think about young children, older relatives and anyone with allergies.
  5. Other pets: Do you already have a dog, a cat or small animals?
  6. Budget: What can you pay each month, and could you cover a large vet bill?

Do: Keep this list. You will check every dog against it.

Task 2: Compare breeds and types

A breed's original job tells you a lot about what the dog will need. A collie was bred to work all day herding sheep. It will not be content with one short walk around the block. Compare dogs on four points:

  • Energy: Working and herding types, such as collies, spaniels and many terriers, usually need plenty of exercise and mental work. Some breeds are calmer, but every dog needs daily exercise and enrichment.
  • Size: A large dog costs more to feed, insure and treat, needs more room and a bigger car, and is harder to handle on the lead while it is still learning.
  • Grooming: Some coats need brushing every day or professional clipping every few weeks. Others need very little care. Remember that no dog is truly allergy-free.
  • Typical behaviour: Guarding breeds may be wary of strangers. Scent hounds may follow their nose and ignore your recall. Some terriers chase small animals. This is instinct, not bad behaviour.

Also check the breed's inherited health problems. For example, flat-faced breeds can have breathing difficulties. Ask which health tests apply to the breed.

Do: Shortlist two or three breeds or types that match your Task 1 answers. Remember that every dog is an individual. Breed tells you what is likely, not what is guaranteed.

Task 3: Consider a rescue dog

Rehoming centres have puppies, adult dogs and older dogs of every type. An adult rescue dog has advantages:

  • Staff already know its personality, energy level and how it gets on with children, cats and other dogs.
  • Many have already had health checks and are microchipped.
  • Centres match dogs to homes and usually offer support after adoption.

A good place to start is a member of the Association of Dogs and Cats Homes (ADCH). Members must meet ADCH's minimum welfare and operational standards. Large charities such as Dogs Trust and the RSPCA also rehome dogs.

Do: Tell the centre what you wrote in Task 1 and let staff suggest dogs. Expect them to ask you questions too. That is a good sign.

Task 4: Spot puppy farms and irresponsible sellers

Puppy farms breed large numbers of puppies with little regard for welfare. Their puppies often have health problems and miss out on early experiences, and some are imported illegally. In England, Lucy's Law (in force since 6 April 2020) bans the sale of puppies and kittens under six months old by third parties such as dealers and pet shops. You must buy directly from the breeder or adopt from a rehoming centre.

Warning signs to walk away from:

  • You cannot see the puppy with its mother, or the mother is said to be "out".
  • The seller offers to meet you in a car park or bring the puppy to you.
  • The house does not look lived in, like a property rented just for showing buyers.
  • The seller rushes you, is evasive, or has several breeds for sale.
  • The puppy is under 8 weeks old.
  • There are no vaccination or microchip records, or the puppy has a pet passport, which can mean it was imported.
  • The sale is arranged through social media with no proper checks.

Know the rules: In England, anyone who breeds three or more litters in 12 months and sells any puppies needs a licence from the local council, as does anyone running a dog-selling business. Licensed breeders must show puppies with their mothers. Puppies must be microchipped and registered by 8 weeks old.

Task 5: Ask the right questions

Use the free Puppy Contract, a toolkit backed by UK welfare charities and vets. A good breeder will be happy to fill it in. Ask:

  1. Can I see the puppy with its mother and littermates in the home where they were born?
  2. Which health tests have the parents had for this breed? Can I see the results?
  3. Has the puppy been vaccinated, wormed and microchipped? Can I see the records?
  4. What has the puppy been fed?
  5. What everyday sights and sounds has the puppy met so far?
  6. Will you take the dog back if I can no longer keep it?

For pedigree dogs, the Royal Kennel Club's Find a Puppy service shows which health tests each litter's parents have had. Its Assured Breeders scheme closed at the end of 2024. At a rescue centre, ask about the dog's history, its behaviour in kennels and what support you get after adoption.

Do: Visit more than once if you can, and never pay before you have seen the puppy with its mother.

Task 6: Count the lifetime cost and commitment

Many dogs live well over a decade. PDSA's 2024 estimates of the minimum lifetime cost are:

  • Small dog: at least £6,200 to £12,000
  • Medium dog: at least £9,000 to £14,000
  • Large dog: at least £8,200 to £18,800

These figures include food, insurance, vaccinations, and flea and worm treatment. They do not include the price of the dog, vet bills for illness or injury, grooming, boarding, day care or training classes. Time matters as much as money: daily walks, training, and arrangements for holidays and working days, for years.

Do: Draw up a monthly budget and a weekly timetable before you commit.

Key takeaways

  • Start with your lifestyle, then find a dog to fit it, not the other way round.
  • Compare energy, size, grooming, typical behaviour and inherited health problems.
  • Adult rescue dogs come with known personalities. ADCH members meet set welfare standards.
  • Always see the puppy with its mother. Never buy one under 8 weeks old, and walk away from any seller who rushes you.
  • In England, Lucy's Law means puppies under six months come only from the breeder or a rehoming centre.
  • Budget for the whole life of the dog, including costs the published estimates leave out.

A 6-question knowledge check follows this lesson in the app, free and without an account.

Keep going: levels 3 and 4 are free

Create a free account to open the next two levels, try the AI tutor, save your progress and pick up where you left off. No card needed.

Next: Level 3, Preparing Your Home and Planning the First Weeks.

Create a free account →See the whole course

More like this