A Moth on a Blackened Tree
Picture Manchester in the middle of the nineteenth century. Hundreds of factory chimneys pour coal smoke into the sky. Soot settles on every window ledge and every washing line, and in time it settles on the trees. The pale lichens that once covered the bark start to die, and the trunks go dark.
The peppered moth rests on those trunks by day. It is a small insect whose white wings are speckled with black, so on a lichen-covered tree it almost disappears. In 1848 a collector in Manchester recorded something unusual, a peppered moth that was almost entirely black. At the time it was a rarity. By 1895, reports put the dark form at around 98 per cent of the peppered moths in the city.
Ask yourself one question. Did any single moth change colour? None did. Every pale moth stayed pale until it died, and every dark moth hatched dark. The change was in the population. Over many generations the proportion of dark moths climbed from almost none to almost all. That shift is the heart of this whole course.
What Evolution Actually Is
In everyday speech, "evolve" can mean almost any kind of change. People say a company has evolved, or a band's sound, or their own taste in coffee. Biologists use the word much more narrowly. Biological evolution is change in the inherited traits of a population over successive generations.
Each part of that sentence does a job. Inherited means the traits are passed from parents to offspring, carried in the biological instructions every living thing receives at conception. Population means a group of the same species living and breeding in the same place, such as the peppered moths of Manchester, the sparrows of one city or the bacteria in a single infection. Over successive generations means the change shows up only as parents give way to offspring, and those offspring to offspring of their own.
If you take any one of those parts away, the change you are looking at is no longer evolution.
The Bodybuilder's Children
Think of a woman who spends ten years lifting weights. Her shoulders broaden and her arms harden, and her body has changed dramatically. Has she evolved? No. Her muscles grew because of what she did, not because her inherited instructions were rewritten. When she has children, they are born with ordinary infant arms. Her decade in the gym does not pass to them.
The same is true of a summer tan, a scar from a childhood fall, or a dog that has learned to fetch the newspaper. Each is a real change in a living body, but it belongs only to that body and ends with it. Biologists call these acquired traits, and they are not the material of evolution.
This is why we say that individuals do not evolve, but populations do. A single creature is dealt its inherited hand at the start of life and keeps it until the end. It may grow, learn, heal or wither, but its inheritance stays fixed. What can change is the mix of inherited traits across a whole population, as some kinds of individuals leave more offspring than others and the next generation carries a different balance.
A deck of cards helps here. Each card is printed once and never changes. But if you keep shuffling, drawing and rebuilding the deck over many rounds, the proportion of hearts to spades can drift a long way from where it began. No card was altered. The deck was. In the same way, a population evolves while its individual members do not.
The Story Ran Backwards Too
The peppered moth story has a sequel. In the twentieth century, cleaner-air laws cut the smoke over Britain's industrial cities. Lichens slowly returned to the bark and the trees grew paler again. From the 1960s onward, the dark form became steadily less common.
This matters because evolution is not a march in one fixed direction. It is change, and change can go either way. Here a population shifted towards dark wings and later shifted back, each time over generations and each time through inherited traits.
Fact and Theory
You will sometimes hear evolution dismissed as "just a theory". The phrase depends on a confusion between two meanings of the word. In everyday speech a theory is a hunch, a guess made over a cup of tea. In science, a theory is something much stronger. The US National Academy of Sciences describes it as a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that can bring together facts, laws, inferences and tested hypotheses.
With that meaning in mind, two separate things come into view. The first is the fact that evolution happens. Populations change in their inherited traits over generations. We can see it in moths, in bacteria and in the fossil record, much as we can see that dropped apples fall. The second is the theory, the body of explanation for how and why that change happens. Gravity offers a neat comparison. That objects fall is a fact. The theories of gravity explain why they fall. Physicists can argue over the finer details of those theories without anyone doubting that a dropped apple will hit the ground.
Evolution works the same way. Scientists still debate the details of how evolution works, which is what a healthy science does. Those debates are about the explanations. They do not cast doubt on whether evolution happens.
Key takeaways
- Biological evolution is change in the inherited traits of a population over successive generations.
- Individuals do not evolve. Each organism keeps its inheritance for life, while the mix of traits across a population can shift from one generation to the next.
- Traits gained during a lifetime, such as muscles, tans, scars and learned tricks, are not inherited and are not evolution.
- Evolutionary change can go in either direction, as the rise and later fall of dark peppered moths shows.
- The fact that evolution happens is separate from the scientific theory that explains how it happens. In science, a theory is a well-substantiated explanation, not a guess.