From Liquid to Solid: The Big Picture
In Level 1 you met milk, the starting point for every cheese. This level covers what happens next: how a vat of liquid milk becomes a solid mass that can be shaped into cheese.
Two ingredients do most of the work:
- Starter cultures: friendly bacteria that make the milk sour.
- Rennet: an enzyme that makes the milk set into a soft gel.
At the end, the milk has split into two parts:
- Curds: soft, solid clumps of milk protein (mainly casein) and fat. These become the cheese.
- Whey: the thin, yellow-green liquid left behind. It is mostly water, with some lactose (milk sugar) and some proteins.
Think of it like making a jelly that you then cut up and drain. The milk sets, it gets cut, and the liquid runs off.
Step by Step: Milk to Drained Curd
Most cheeses follow the same basic order. Learn these seven steps:
- Warm the milk. The cheesemaker brings the milk to a set temperature so that the bacteria and the enzyme can work.
- Add starter cultures. Bacteria go into the milk and start turning lactose into lactic acid. This stage is often called ripening the milk.
- Add rennet. The milk is stirred briefly and then left completely still.
- Let it set. Over a period of time (often around half an hour to an hour, depending on the recipe), the milk firms into a single soft gel, like a smooth custard.
- Cut the curd. Knives or wire frames cut the gel into pieces. Small pieces release more whey and give a drier, firmer cheese. Large pieces hold more moisture and give a softer cheese.
- Stir and (often) heat. Gentle stirring and warming squeeze more whey out of the pieces of curd.
- Drain the whey. The curds are separated from the whey, ready to be shaped, salted and matured.
What to do: Say the sequence aloud: warm, culture, rennet, set, cut, stir, drain. The two most common mistakes are adding rennet before the cultures and draining before cutting.
The Job of Starter Cultures
Starter cultures are selected lactic acid bacteria. Their main job is acidification: they eat lactose and produce lactic acid. That acid matters in several ways:
- It helps the rennet work. Rennet sets milk better once it is slightly acidic.
- It helps curds release whey. More acid means the curds shed liquid more easily.
- It protects the cheese. Rising acidity makes conditions harder for many unwanted microbes.
- It builds flavour. Different cultures give different tastes and aromas. This is one reason why two cheeses made from the same milk can taste quite different.
Analogy: Cultures are the seasoning and preparation crew. They get the milk into the right condition and start building its character.
The Job of Rennet
Rennet is a coagulant: it makes the milk set. Its key active enzyme is chymosin. Chymosin cuts a small part off the casein proteins in milk. Normally that part keeps the proteins apart. Once it is removed, the proteins link together into a net that traps fat and water. The result is the gel you saw in Step 4.
Analogy: If cultures are the preparation crew, rennet is the builder that turns loose proteins into a solid structure.
What to do: Keep the two jobs apart in your head:
- Cultures → acid (sourness, flavour, protection)
- Rennet → set (turning liquid into a gel)
Animal Rennet vs Vegetarian Rennet
This is where your shopping habits come in.
Animal rennet traditionally comes from the fourth stomach (the abomasum) of young calves, where chymosin helps the calf digest its mother's milk. Because the calf has to be slaughtered to get it, cheese made with animal rennet is not suitable for vegetarians.
Vegetarian coagulants do the same job without using an animal's stomach:
- Microbial rennet: enzymes made by fermenting certain fungi.
- Fermentation-produced chymosin (FPC): microorganisms that make chymosin almost identical to the calf version. It is widely used in industrial cheesemaking. Some vegetarians question it because the original gene came from a calf.
- Thistle rennet: enzymes from the cardoon thistle, used in some traditional Mediterranean cheeses, especially in Spain and Portugal.
Why it matters, and what to check
- Some famous cheeses must use animal rennet. The protected recipe for Parmigiano Reggiano allows only calf rennet. Grana Padano also uses calf rennet.
- Other classics are usually not vegetarian. These include Gorgonzola, Pecorino Romano, Gruyère and Emmental.
- Read the label. UK law has no legal definition of "vegetarian". Look for a clear "suitable for vegetarians" statement. At a counter, ask the cheesemonger which coagulant was used.
- Check allergens as well. Under UK Food Standards Agency rules, milk is one of the 14 allergens that must be emphasised on labels, and every cheese contains it. Some cheeses add others: Grana Padano contains lysozyme taken from hen's egg white, so egg also appears on its allergen list.
Key Takeaways
- Milk becomes curds (the solids that become cheese) and whey (the liquid that is drained off).
- The order is: warm → add cultures → add rennet → set → cut → stir/heat → drain.
- Cultures make lactic acid, which brings flavour and protection and helps the rennet work.
- Rennet (chymosin) makes the milk proteins link together into a gel.
- Animal rennet comes from calves' stomachs and is not vegetarian. Microbial, FPC and thistle coagulants are the vegetarian alternatives.
- Parmigiano Reggiano must use calf rennet. Always check labels for vegetarian suitability and for allergens such as milk and egg.